Alley Cat Lounge, reviewed September 30, 2005
   All Stars Sports & Daiquiri Bar, reviewed September 2, 2004
* Bazbeaux Pizza, reviewed May 13, 2005
   Binkley's Kitchen & Bar, reviewed April 1, 2005
   Broad Ripple Brewpub, reviewed July 8, 2004
   Broad Ripple High School Cafeteria, reviewed December 10, 2004
   Circle City Pizza, reviewed July 22, 2005
   Chumley's Beerhouse & Grill, reviewed February 4, 2005
   Domino's Pizza, reviewed January 7, 2005
   Donatos, reviewed November 12, 2004
   Fazoli's, reviewed October 15, 2004
   Greek's Pizzeria, reviewed November 21, 2008
   Jack's Pizza, reviewed May 27, 2005
   The Jazz Kitchen, reviewed November 11, 2005
   Just Judy's Restaurant & Pub, reviewed April 15, 2005
   Keystone Sports Review, reviewed June 10, 2005
   Kroger Deli, reviewed March 24, 2006
   Marco's Pizza, reviewed August 5, 2005
   Marco's Restaurant & Lounge, reviewed August 19, 2004
   Milano's Sunny's Pizza, reviewed June 24, 2004
   Moe & Johnny's, reviewed October 29, 2004
   Monical's Pizza, reviewed June 11, 2010
* Napolese, an Artisanal Pizzeria, reviewed August 6, 2010
   Noble Roman's, reviewed April 29, 2005
   Old Pro's Table, reviewed October 1, 2004
   Paco's Cantina, reviewed July 23, 2004
   Papa John's Pizza, reviewed June 24, 2005
   Papa Murphy's Take 'N' Bake, reviewed September 16, 2004
   Pat Flynn's Public House, reviewed July 8, 2005
   Pizza di Roma, reviewed December 24, 2004
   Pizza Express, reviewed November 26, 2004
   Pizza Hut, reviewed March 18, 2005
   Pizza Magia, reviewed August 5, 2004
   Ripple Bagel & Deli, reviewed October 7, 2005
* Some Guys Pizza Pasta Grill, reviewed August 19, 2005
   Stone Mug Cafe, reviewed September 2, 2005
   Thr3e Wise Men, reviewed March 18, 2011
* Union Jack Pub, reviewed June 10, 2004
* WB Pizza, reviewed February 18, 2005
   'ZA, reviewed August 7, 2009

* Pizza Scene top pick